Determining Causation In A Personal Injury Case—Proving the Accident (and NOT Something Else) is the Cause of the Claimed Injury

FREE Personal Injury Case Consultation1.866 INJURY 2or1.866.465.8792
Causation and Personal Injury Claims

When a person is involved in an accident, that person (the victim) must show by a preponderance of the evidence (i.e., more likely than not) that the subject incident was the cause of the victim's injuries and damages. In other words, the burden of proof is on the injured victim (and his or her personal injury lawyer) to prove the accident caused the injury. For example, if a person was rear ended in a car collision and claims neck and/or back injuries, it is well understood that such injuries occur in and are "caused" by such collisions. In fact, such injuries are so common in rear end car collisions that most of us are well aware of the common term "whiplash injury" given to such injuries. In such cases, proving causation is usually not very difficult. However, if the victim claims much more severe injuries with much more involved care and treatment than is usually seen in such rear end car collisions, or perhaps a knee or shoulder injury that is usually not seen in such collisions (but sometimes certainly is seen), then it may be necessary for the victim to go through greater measures to show or prove that this particular collision caused such injuries. In other words, the burden of proof falls on the injured victim to show how and why the subject collision caused the unusual or unexpected injury. This can be done by an experienced personal injury attorney using experts and detailed reports of the damage to the car, such as proof of damage that is not readily visible or some hidden structural or frame damage that usually means the forces of impact actually were greater than believed or, in the case of a knee injury, that the victim's knee was impacted by something inside the vehicle, such as the dashboard, steering wheel or something else, and there was no evidence of any prior knee injury or problem (e.g., by obtaining then reviewing the victim's prior medical records).

Car Accident
Car collision causing personal injuries

Sometimes the victim is elderly or suffered a prior accident that did not completely heal or has some other pre-existing medical condition, making the victim frail or much more susceptible in even a relatively minor accident to injury and aggravation of pre-existing problems. That later example of someone with a prior injury or medical condition causing someone to be injured to a greater degree than might otherwise be expected is often referred to as the “egg shell plaintiff”, referring to someone who is frail and more easily breakable than would be expected, sort of like an “egg shell” is frail and breakable. In such cases it is necessary to obtain the prior medical history and records of the injured victim for the treating medical doctors and specialists who are providing health care services in the new accident case to use to help explain the victim’s injuries and medical conditions.

It is not unusual for a claimant to have suffered a prior neck or back injury that is aggravated or exacerbated by a new car accident collision. In such situations, it is necessary to understand the claimant’s prior injury and how the claimant was doing just before the new collision compared to right after the new collision, and try to apportion the injuries and damages between the pre-existing condition and all new and aggravated injuries caused by the new collision or accident. This is not an exact science and there is no specific formula to do this. Instead, it is simply a matter of proof and reasonable judgment based upon medical records, reports and testimony of medical experts and, of course, testimony of the claimant and those who know the claimant best, such as spouses, other family members, friends and co-workers.

It's easy to contact us
There is NO charge for our initial consultation — it is absolutely FREE!

Over 40 years experience successfully handling thousands of personal injury & wrongful death accident cases in California!

If you had a personal injury, our personal injury & wrongful death accident lawyers offer an absolutely FREE & CONFIDENTIAL case consultation and evaluation and we work on a contingency fee. That means there is NO fee until you WIN and then the fee comes out of the recovery usually paid by the other parties’ insurance company and not out of your own pocket.

There are many easy ways to contact us 24/7:

  • Please call us Toll Free at 866 INJURY 2 or 866.465.8792 (after hours please dial "1")

  • You may also call us at 818.222.3400 (again, after hours, please dial "1")
  • Simply click here for our quick and easy contact form to tell us about your personal injury or other injury accident.

  • Send us an email anytime to info@WalchLaw.com.


We offer FREE consultations and evaluations to those hurt in accidents in Los Angeles, Kern, Orange, Riverside, San Fernando Valley, San Bernardino, Ventura and throughout all of California and there is NO fee until you WIN!

We look forward to speaking with you today and helping you resolve your injury accident legal problems.

Liability In A Personal Injury Case—Who Is Responsible?
Injuries & Damages In A Personal Injury Case—How Badly Was The Victim Hurt and How Much is My Case Worth?
Determining Causation In A Personal Injury Case—Proving the Accident (and NOT Something Else) is the Cause of the Claimed Injury
Contact Us If You Suffered A Personal Injury In Any Accident

SE HABLA ESPAÑOL / SA ATIN PO ITO / FALAMOS PORTUGUÊS / 我們講普通話和廣東話

FREE CONSULTATION * NO FEE UNTIL YOU WIN !

Client Reviews
You guys did a great job in settling my case! Hope you all do well and prosper. Thank you for a job well done.
★★★★★
We had two prior attorneys who were unable to settle our car accident case. We then hired Gary and Robert Walch and they not only got us both great settlements, but personally spent time with us explaining everything clearly. We couldn't be happier. Thank you! A.M. and M.A.
★★★★★
Dear Gary, I just want to thank you for working so hard on my case! I know at times we were a bit difficult, but you did a great job. I thank you and your son for good results. I will pass your number on to any one that I run across who may need a PI attorney! I send you warm regards. Julie B.
★★★★★
Dear Gary, I just wanted to tell you how much I appreciate all your efforts on my behalf. The car accident was a very traumatizing experience for me. But knowing that I could trust you and your son, Robert, helped alleviate my fears and worries. Carmella C.
★★★★★
Thank you for all of your hard work and thank you for making it so easy over e-mail for me. I'm a busy working mom of an Autistic 5 year old son and you guys were great. I will definitely recommend your services to family and friends. Edna G.
★★★★★